New York Classic Pizza Joint (Babylon) - Bayshore Menu skip to main content skip to footer

Bayshore Menu


Large Cheese Pizza 18”: $15.95

Small Cheese Pizza 16”: $13.50

Gluten-Free Pizza 12”: $12.95

Cauliflower Crust Pizza 12”: $12.95

Sicilian: $18.95

Brooklyn: $21.95

Grandma: $21.95

Drunken Grandma: $21.95

White Pie: $22.95

Margherita: $21.95
Fresh mozzarella, tomato sauce, and basil.

New York Pizza: $21.95
Square thin crust, fresh mozzarella, with sweet tomato sauce.

Pizza Toppings

Full Pie Toppings: $4.50 | Half Pie Toppings: $2.50
Pepperoni | Meatball | Sausage | Bacon | Peppers | Onions | Mushrooms | Garlic | Extra Cheese | Ham | Olives | Tomato

Add Special Full Pie Topping: $5.00
Add Special Half Pie Topping: $3.00
Fried Chicken | Grilled Chicken | Spinach | Broccoli | Eggplant | Broccoli Rabe

Add Sesame Seed Crust: $3.25

Add Everything Seed Crust: $3.50


16oz Soup Served with Bread

Chicken Wings (8): $9.75
Plain, Buffalo, BBQ, or Thai

Fried Calamari: $11.50
Marinara, Buffalo, Thai, or Cherry Pepper

Baked Clams: $12.50

Chicken Fingers with Fries: $11.00

Tortellini in Brodo: $5.95

Mozzarella Sticks (6): $7.50

Sicilian Rice Ball: $5.95
Add Mozzarella: $1.00

Garlic Bread: $3.95
Add Mozzarella:$1.00


Garden Salad: $7.95
Mixed greens, onions, tomatoes, cucumbers, olives, carrots, and peppers

Caesar Salad: $8.95
Romaine, croutons, shaved parmesan cheese, and caesar dressing

Greek Salad: $9.95
Mixed greens, kalamata olives, peppers, tomato, and feta cheese

Caprese Salad: $11.95
Fresh mozzarella, tomato, basil, extra virgin olive oil, balsamic glaze over mixed greens

Stefano’s Salad: $12.95
Belgium endives, walnuts, cranberries, gorgonzola cheese and green apples

Baked Pasta

Baked Ziti: $11.95

Baked Ziti Siciliano: $13.95

Baked Stuffed Shells: $12.95

Baked Ravioli: $12.95

Baked Tortellini: $12.95

Lasagna: $12.95

Specialty Pasta

Choice of: Penne, Rigatoni, Spaghetti, Linguini, or Orecchiette

Add to any Pasta:
Grilled or Fried Chicken: $5.00
Shrimp: $7.95

Alla Vodka: $14.95

Bolognese: $15.95

Alfredo: $12.95

Pasta Primavera: $13.95

Broccoli Rabe with Sausage: $14.95

Genovese: $14.95
Pesto sauce with a touch of cream

Toscano: $16.95
Spinach, mushrooms, and shrimp in a pink sauce

Linguini Clam Sauce (Red or White): $15.95

Spaghetti with Meatballs: $14.95

Broccoli Garlic & Oil: $12.95

Garlic & Oil: $9.95

Marinara: $10.95

Tomato Sauce: $10.95

Rolls, Calzones, and Pinwheels

Calzone (Baked or Fried): $6.75
Add any topping: $1.00

Family Style Calzone: $18.95
Add Topping: $3.00

Pepperoni | Meatball | Sausage | Bacon | Peppers | Onions | Mushrooms | Garlic | Extra Cheese | Ham | Olives | Spinach | Broccoli | Tomato

Meat Stromboli: $5.95

Veggie Stromboli: $5.95

Chicken Roll: $6.95

Buffalo Chicken Roll: $6.95

Sausage & Pepper Roll: $6.95

Eggplant Roll: $6.95

Spinach Roll: $6.95

Ham & Cheese Roll: $6.95

Pepperoni Pinwheel: $3.95

Broccoli Pinwheel: $3.95

Garlic Knots (6): $2.50

Garlic Knots (12): $5.00

Specialty Pies

Buffalo Chicken: $26.95

BBQ Chicken: $13.50

Chicken Bacon Ranch: $26.95

Chicken Vodka: $26.95

Chicken Marsala: $26.95

Chicken Francese: $26.95

Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad Pie: $26.95

Chicken Parmigiana: $24.95

Shrimp Pesto Pizza: $28.95

Fried Calamari Pizza: $26.95

Broccoli Rabe and Sausage: $24.95

Eggplant Parmigiana Pizza: $24.95

Spinach & Artichoke: $23.95

The Robbie Mozz: $26.95
Fresh mozzarella, tomato, basil, and drizzled balsamic glaze

Giovanni Special: $26.95
Chicken cutlet, roasted red peppers, balsamic glaze, and fresh basil

Stefano Special: $26.95
Mushroom cream, with a touch of cognac sauce, covered with sundried tomato, truffle oil, and shaved parmesan cheese

Old Fashioned: $22.95
Provolone, marinara sauce, mozzarella, and parmesan cheese

White Parma: $25.95
Prosciutto, arugula, shaved parmesan, and a touch of truffle oil

Calabrisella: $24.95
Hot soppressata, two types of mozzarella, and a touch of honey

Eggplant Oreganata: $24.95
Grilled eggplant, fresh mozzarella, a touch of marinara, oreganata bread crumbs, pecorino romano cheese and basil


16oz Soup Served with Bread

Lentil: $5.95

Minestrone: $5.95

Pasta Fagioli: $5.95

Stracciatella: $5.95

Tortellini in Brodo: $5.95


Add Fresh Mozzarella: $1.00

Chicken Parmigiana Hero: $9.95

Meatball Parmigiana Hero: $9.95

Eggplant Parmigiana Hero: $8.95

Veal Parmigiana Hero: $10.95

Sausage Parmigiana Hero: $9.95

Shrimp Parmigiana Hero: $10.95

Sausage & Peppers Hero: $8.95

Peppers & Egg Hero: $7.95

Potato & Egg Hero: $7.95

The Godfather: $10.95
Salami, pepperoni, ham, provolone, lettuce, tomato, and onions

Chicken Caprese: $10.95
Grilled chicken, fresh mozzarella, tomato, roasted red pepper, and pesto

Chicken Antico: $10.95
Fried chicken cutlet, fresh mozzarella, roasted red pepper, and balsamic glaze

Grilled Chicken & Broccoli Rabe Hero: $11.95


Served with a choice of pasta or salad


Chicken Parmigiana: $16.95
Lightly fried, baked with tomato sauce and mozzarella

Chicken Francese: $16.95
Egg battered, sauteed in a white wine, lemon, and butter sauce

Chicken Marsala: $16.95
Sauteed in a marsala wine sauce with shiitake mushrooms

Chicken Scarpariello: $17.95
Sauteed chicken breast with sausage, cherry peppers

Chicken Milanese: $17.95
Lightly fried chicken cutlet, chopped mozzarella, tomato, basil, onion, and balsamic glaze

Chicken Cacciatore: $17.95
Chicken breast sauteed with mushrooms, onions, and peppers in a light tomato sauce


Veal Parmigiana: $18.95
Lightly fried veal cutlet with tomato sauce and mozzarella

Veal Francese: $18.95
Egg battered and sauteed in a white wine, lemon, and butter sauce

Veal Milanese: $18.95
Lightly fried chicken cutlet over mesclun salad

Veal Marsala: $18.95
Sauteed in a marsala wine sauce with shiitake mushrooms


Eggplant Parmigiana: $14.95
Lightly fried eggplant, baked with tomato sauce and mozzarella

Eggplant Rollatine: $16.95
Stuffed with ricotta, ham, and mozzarella, baked with tomato sauce and mozzarella


Shrimp Parmigiana: $18.95
Lightly fried shrimp, baked with marinara sauce and mozzarella

Shrimp Scampi: $18.95
Sauteed in white wine, garlic, fresh herbs, and lemon


Meatballs (3): $4.95

Sausage (2): $3.95

Sauteed Broccoli: $4.95

Sauteed Spinach: $5.95

Sauteed Broccoli Rabe: $6.95