New York Classic Pizza Joint (Babylon) - Reviews skip to main content skip to footer

Reviews

We ordered delivery yesterday and were happy with the fast turn around. We ordered a large Caesar salad with grilled chicken which was quite good. We also ordered a large Neapolitan plain pie with the everything spice crust. The flavors on the pizza were quite good as well. My only qualm or issue was they did not let the hot cheese o ... read more
Paul Mercieca via google.com - Jul 25, 2021
The new owner is amazing! Best pizza and garlic knots around. We drive from a few towns away just for our favorites and they never disappoint!!
jennifer Mohammed via google.com - Jul 24, 2021
I’ve been to this spot a couple of times and thought I should write a review, because it quickly became the favorite pizza place in Babylon! This restaurant offers great prices, awesome food, and great costumer service. I always love dining in with the train going around the top of the store and great music! Definitely recommend for ... read more
Dom Catania via google.com - Jul 19, 2021
Very suprised by how well everything looked and tasted here!!! new owners were extremely friendly unlike previous owners. this is the first time i have ever wrote a review for a place but i need to let everyone know this was the best pizza i’ve had in a long time ... read more
Frank R via google.com - Jul 19, 2021
Delicious as always and staff is always friendly and professional..... great place for kids. Railroad train decorations are so cute ... read more
Glaydz Prezzz via google.com - Jul 18, 2021
First time in Babylon - great pizza, even better service!
Hunter Cox via google.com - Jul 15, 2021
I can't believe how AMAZING the pizza is! I stopped by to try because I saw they were under new ownership! I ended up ordering a New York Pizza! I loved it !
Andrea Fortunato via google.com - Jun 11, 2021
Excellent service the best pizza I have ever tried ... .. it is super juicy and delicious flavors.
Gerencia Movertrans via google.com - May 24, 2021
Today I give a new chance to this place and I'm really glad I did it cause food and service is amazing. I recommend the Eggplant oreganata slice!!!
santi Vera via google.com - May 24, 2021
This place has changed owners twice over the last two years, so I didn’t have high hopes. I was very pleasantly surprised! Hubby and i popped in today after working in the yard for a slice or two. The Babylon slice was absolutely fantastic!! I will definitely be back again to try different slices and the dinners.
Lori Granholm via google.com - May 23, 2021
Delicious grandma pie and the owner Frankie is a sweetheart Definitely stop buy and have some pizza🍕💕 ... read more
Loretta Long via google.com - May 16, 2021
New owners, new recipes, new ginos!! Amazing food and service ... read more
Gabriela Vera via google.com - May 11, 2021
Gino's is one of my favorite places to eat at. I like the service. They are always nice.
Sonia Johnson via google.com - Apr 24, 2021
Gino's is right down the road from me. It's not my favorite. But let me tell you when I had the meat lovers pizza,and my girlfriend had the vegetable stuffed pizza. It was the best work that I have seen from this place. Compliments to the chef , I'm sure the boss will throw you a few more shekels an hour. I looked at the menu I d ... read more
John Peterson via google.com - Apr 6, 2021
Everything seasoning crust is insanely good. Best specialty slices around, and great regular pizza as well.
kfrodes via google.com - Mar 27, 2021
Food was good, but they added and item to my order, which I didn’t request and they charged me for it. When I wrote to inform them of the error, they didn’t respond.
Sandra Vega via google.com - Mar 24, 2021
Por la ropa de bebe ... read more
Mejia Eva via google.com - Feb 15, 2021
The food is great pizza best I ever had service nice people and helpful place spotless ... read more
Lisa Purcell via google.com - Feb 12, 2021
Great Pizza. Reasonable prices. Great selection. Friendly service. Everything served fresh. Just steps away from the Babylon train station. On the corner of Deer Park Ave. Go get your slice or sandwich. Ed ... read more
Edward Lennon via google.com - Feb 4, 2021
Best pizza around nice staff ... read more
Darren Johnson via google.com - Jan 2, 2021
Nice pizza. Excellent.
wilfred erubiel via google.com - Dec 19, 2020
Great Pizza & Knots!
Eric Jansen via google.com - Dec 14, 2020
Good ... read more
Juan M. Martinez via google.com - Dec 3, 2020
The BEST Sicilian Slice....anywhere !
stephen kusa via google.com - Nov 18, 2020
We've been going to Gino's for a long time & we stopped going because the food just didn't taste that good anymore but 1 night while walking through the village we decided to get a slice of pizza & truthfully you were the only place open because all the other pizza places close kinda early, well I don't know if you have a new chef or ... read more
Sherri Maas via google.com - Nov 1, 2020
Good food and service!
Que Line via google.com - Oct 31, 2020
Chicken Parmesan Chicken Fingers chicken roll everything's good ... read more
LONG ISLAND G4LIFE via google.com - Aug 9, 2020
Macaroni pizza is a must!
Eric Moon via google.com - Aug 1, 2020
My family LOVES their take-out and delivery! Can’t wait to visit in person so my son can enjoy watc
My family LOVES their take-out and delivery! Can’t wait to visit in person so my son can enjoy watching the train go around again...
Mariana Pineda via facebook.com - Jul 12, 2020
They make me a special clam and garlic pie it's great ... read more
M M via google.com - Jun 30, 2020
Loved the Veggie Personal Pizza ... read more
Alex C. Elie via google.com - Jun 28, 2020
We’ve been customers from the beginning!!!😋
We’ve been customers from the beginning!!!😋 ... read more
Maria Broulis Hansen via facebook.com - Apr 24, 2020
stuffed veggie pie was awesome.
stuffed veggie pie was awesome.
Gloria Benanchietti-Frouxides via facebook.com - Apr 4, 2020
Thank you Gino's of Babylon for the amazing 10 for $50 heat & eat special!! Sooooo... much... food!
Thank you Gino's of Babylon for the amazing 10 for $50 heat & eat special!! Sooooo... much... food!!! Can't wait to try them all!!!
Jennifer Sacks via facebook.com - Apr 2, 2020
The best! Wish I still lived nearby for the pizza!!
Carlos Schmidt via google.com - Mar 13, 2020
a Babylon staple, thank you to the long-time owner for over 35 years of hard-work and perseverance. I am confident the new owners will take your well-earned legacy in pleasing and serving delicious Italian food for the community & build upon it. Molte grazie.
Michael Cosentino via google.com - Mar 9, 2020
I dine in this lovely place quite often! This is my favorite restaurant to have a bite. I visit this place regularly. The cooking is fantastic, the workers are professional and the payment is decent. I like eating in this place for a tasty lunch.
Houston Keller via google.com - Mar 3, 2020
Not too shabby. Great sauce and OK cheese ... read more
Ace Dorvay via google.com - Feb 26, 2020
I have been eating here for as long as I can remember. Gino’s not on made for delightful nights in
I have been eating here for as long as I can remember. Gino’s not on made for delightful nights in at home but also supported many late nights working at my father’s florist in town during various holidays, not to mention countless lunches while attending Babylon high school. A slice of Gino’s pizza is an instant trip back to my ch ... read more
Lauren VanDeinse via facebook.com - Feb 21, 2020
Local multiple location -- that alone tells you it is good.
JimmY MonT via google.com - Feb 11, 2020
Toop pizza crocante ... read more
Fabiana Carpenter via google.com - Jan 23, 2020
Been going to Gino’s since he was a one man shop next to the broken oar, always happy with the pizza!
Michael LaMancusa via google.com - Jan 10, 2020
Love this place, best employees and their pizza is amazing ... read more
Rachel Rosenthal via google.com - Dec 28, 2019
Great food. Warm atmosphere ... read more
5thelementalist via google.com - Dec 28, 2019
Pizza looked old and was way too greasy.
Nathan Webb via google.com - Nov 9, 2019
Really good pizza and fun specialty slices. Employees are nice. There's a calm vibe despite the train station being next door ... read more
Luisa Coronado via google.com - Oct 24, 2019
Great option when ordering pizza and italian
But I have ordered from here through Uber Eats only. Its in the downtown strip so is at a great location; parking can be an issue. Good number of options. Pizza is very good. Calzones we have ordered have been good.
randomtravelz via tripadvisor.com - Sep 6, 2019
Better places out there but not terrible ... read more
Domenick Palmeri via google.com - Aug 26, 2019
If you have ever eaten at Gino's of Farmingdale you know who Gino's of west Babylon is. After moving to Florida 18 years ago I still have them overnight me 4 sicilian pies every year for my super bowl party... I'm glad I now have 2 locations to get a slice of the worlds best pizza when I'm back on Long Island.....
Christian Aguirre via google.com - Aug 9, 2019
A small but great Pizza Place. Basically a take out Pizzaria. But the food is great and the people are nice and friendly. Give them a try. You will like the place.
anthony C tumbiolo via google.com - Jul 29, 2019
Gluten free pizza is so good, staff is warm and on top of every order.
Mary Christy via google.com - Jul 18, 2019
Best pizza in town! Yummy!
Debra L. Jimenez via google.com - Jul 17, 2019
Great 🍕 ... read more
Debra L. Jimenez via google.com - Jul 5, 2019
Food was great ... read more
William Sadousky via google.com - Jul 5, 2019
Excellent pizza. Very clean restaurant. Friendly service.
Seth S via google.com - Jun 17, 2019
Great ... read more
IFernando Ford via google.com - Jun 8, 2019
Want To Tell Us About Your Experience?
GoogleMyBusinessFoursquareFacebookYelpZomatoTwitterTrip AdvisorYouTubeGrouponInstagramOpen TablePinterestZagatFlickrLinkedInTumblrTheKnotWeddingWire