New York Classic Pizza Joint (Babylon) - Bay Shore Catering Menu skip to main content skip to footer

Bay Shore Catering Menu

Appetizers:                                  

Half Tray Serves 6-8 Portions | Full Tray Serves 12-15 Portions

Stuffed Mushrooms ~ Half Tray $45.00 | Full Tray $60.00
Chicken Wings (Buffalo, BBQ, Thai or Plain) ~ Half Tray $39.99 | Full Tray $69.99
Chicken Tenders ~ Half Tray $39.99 | Full Tray $69.99
Baked Clams ~ Half Tray $45.00 | Full Tray $85.00
Fried Calamari ~ Half Tray $46.99 | Full Tray $86.99
Mozzarella Sticks ~ Half Tray $39.99 | Full Tray $69.99

Zucchini Sticks ~ Half Tray $39.99 | Full Tray $69.99

Rice Balls ~ Half Tray $34.99 | Full Tray $59.99

Salads:                                        

Half Tray Serves 6-8 Portions | Full Tray Serves 12-15 Portions

Garden Salad ~ Half Tray $29.99 | Full Tray $52.99

Caesar Salad ~ Half Tray $29.99 | Full Tray $52.99
Caesar Salad with Chicken ~ Half Tray $44.99 | Full Tray $69.99
Greek Salad ~ Half Tray $40.00 | Full Tray $65.00

Caprese Salad ~ Half Tray $44.99 | Full Tray $69.99

Stefano Salad ~ Half Tray $39.99 | Full Tray $74.99
Calamari Salad ~ Half Tray $40.00 | Full Tray $55.00

Baked Pastas                                 

Half Tray Serves 6-8 Portions | Full Tray Serves 12-15 Portions

Lasagna ~ Half Tray $45.00 | Full Tray $75.00
Baked Manicotti ~ Half Tray $40.00 | Full Tray $70.00
Baked Stuffed Shells ~ Half Tray $40.00 | Full Tray $70.00
Baked Ravioli ~ Half Tray $40.00 | Full Tray $70.00
Baked Ziti ~ Half Tray $40.00 | Full Tray $70.00

Select One of Our Imported Pastas and
Homemade Sauces                        

Half Tray Serves 6-8 Portions | Full Tray Serves 15-20 Portions

Pasta Choices:
Penne, Rigatoni, Spaghetti, Linguini, or Tortellini

Alla Vodka ~ Half Tray $40.00 | Full Tray $70.00
Alfredo ~ Half Tray $40.00 | Full Tray $70.00
Bolognese ~ Half Tray $50.00 | Full Tray $85.00
Marinara ~ Half Tray $40.00 | Full Tray $70.00
Genovese Pesto Sauce with a touch of cream ~ Half Tray $40.00 | Full Tray $70.00
Tomato Sauce ~ Half Tray $40.00 | Full Tray $70.00
Primavera ~ Half Tray $40.00 | Full Tray $70.00
Garlic & Oil ~ Half Tray $40.00 | Full Tray $70.00
Meat Sauce ~ Half Tray $50.00 | Full Tray $85.00

Vegetables                                       

Half Tray Serves 6-8 Portions | Full Tray Serves 15-20 Portions


Broccoli Rabe
 ~ Half Tray $60.00 | Full Tray $90.00

Sauteed Broccoli ~ Half Tray $35.00 | Full Tray $60.00
Sauteed Spinach ~ Half Tray $35.00 | Full Tray $60.00

Chicken Entrees                              

Half Tray Serves 6-8 Portions | Full Tray Serves 12-15 Portions

Chicken Parmigiana ~ Half Tray $55.00 | Full Tray $90.00
Chicken Francese ~ Half Tray $60.00 | Full Tray $99.00
Chicken Marsala ~ Half Tray $60.00 | Full Tray $99.00
Chicken Milanese ~ Half Tray $55.00 | Full Tray $90.00
Chicken Scarpariello ~ Half Tray $65.00 | Full Tray $110.00

Veal Entrees                                    

Half Tray Serves 6-8 Portions | Full Tray Serves 12-15 Portions

Veal Parmigiana ~ Half Tray $75.00 | Full Tray $125.00
Veal Francese ~ Half Tray $85.00 | Full Tray $130.00
Veal Marsala ~ Half Tray $85.00 | Full Tray $130.00

Old Time Favorites                         

Half Tray Serves 6-8 Portions | Full Tray Serves 12-15 Portions

Eggplant Parmigiana ~ Half Tray $45.00 | Full Tray $80.00
Eggplant Rollatini ~ Half Tray $55.00 | Full Tray $90.00
Meatballs ~ Half Tray $45.00 | Full Tray $80.00
Sausage and Peppers ~ Half Tray $45.00 | Full Tray $80.00

Seafood                                           

Half Tray Serves 6-8 Portions | Full Tray Serves 12-15 Portions

Shrimp Oreganata ~ Half Tray $69.99 | Full Tray $129.99

Calamari Marinara ~ Half Tray $65.00 | Full Tray $120.00

Linguini in Red or White Clam Sauce ~ Half Tray $60.00 | Full Tray $110.00

Shrimp and Clams Fra Diavolo ~ Half Tray $69.99 | Full Tray $129.99

Shrimp Scampi ~ Half Tray $69.99 | Full Tray $129.99

Party Heros                                  

3 Foot Minimum

Cold Italian or Cold American Hero ~ $19.95 Per Foot
Chicken Parmigiana ~ $19.95 Per Foot

Chicken Vodka Fresh Mozzarella ~ $19.95 Per Foot

Chicken Caprese ~ $19.95 Per Foot

Chicken Broccoli Rabe ~ $19.95 Per Foot

Meatball Parmigiana ~ $19.95 Per Foot

Eggplant Parmigiana ~ $19.95 Per Foot